Guide · Sentencing record
How to Write a Mitigation Letter for Federal Sentencing
A letter to the judge is evidence. It shows the court who the defendant is, through the eyes of someone who knows them. This guide covers the law behind these letters, who should write them, a structure that works and the mistakes that weaken them.
Bottom line. Federal judges may consider "any information concerning the background, character and conduct of the defendant, unless otherwise prohibited by law" (USSG §1B1.4; 18 U.S.C. § 3661). The strongest letters are specific, firsthand and honest, and they go to the court through defense counsel.
Why judges read these letters
- The statute. "No limitation shall be placed on the information concerning the background, character, and conduct of a person convicted of an offense which a court of the United States may receive and consider for the purpose of imposing an appropriate sentence" (18 U.S.C. § 3661).
- The sentencing factors. The court must consider "the history and characteristics of the defendant" (18 U.S.C. § 3553(a)(1)), among the other § 3553(a) factors.
- The guidelines. USSG §1B1.4 restates that the court may consider this information "without limitation."
Letters supplement the presentence report, which already describes the defendant's history and characteristics (Fed. R. Crim. P. 32(d)(2)(A)). A good letter adds detail the report cannot.
Who should write
Family
Concrete examples of responsibilities: caregiving, support, daily routines that depend on the defendant.
Employers and colleagues
Work history, reliability, what the person did for others at work and what employment looks like after sentencing.
Community and faith leaders
Service the writer personally saw, with dates and scale where known.
Treatment providers
Clinical facts within the provider's professional knowledge. A treatment progress letter is not a character reference.
A few specific letters from people who truly know the defendant usually say more than many generic ones. See what to include in character letters.
A structure that works
- Who you are. Name, occupation, city. One or two sentences.
- How you know the defendant. The relationship, how long and how often you see each other.
- You know about the case. One sentence acknowledging that you know about the conviction. No argument about the facts.
- What you have personally seen. Two or three specific examples, with when and where. This is the core of the letter.
- Change and accountability you have observed. Only what you have actually seen since the case began.
- Impact and support going forward. Concrete facts about responsibilities to others and the support you will provide.
- Close and contact information. Sign it, date it and include a way to reach you.
Example outline (structure only, not a real letter)
Dear Judge [Name]: I am [name], a [occupation] in [city]. I have known [defendant] for [number] years as [relationship]. I understand that [he or she] has been convicted and will be sentenced by your Honor. [Specific example 1 with time and place.] [Specific example 2.] Since the case began, I have seen [specific observed change]. [Concrete responsibility or support facts.] I can be reached at [phone or email]. Respectfully, [name, date].
What to avoid
- Disputing guilt, blaming others or minimizing the offense.
- Asking for a specific sentence or criticizing the prosecution or the court.
- Exaggeration or anything the writer cannot personally support. Credibility is the whole value of the letter.
- Form letters and copied language. Judges notice repeated phrases.
- Facts about the case or other people that counsel has not reviewed.
How letters reach the judge
Letters go to defense counsel, not to the court. Counsel decides which letters to submit and how, typically together with the federal sentencing memorandum. Ask counsel about format (signed PDF or original), the address line and the deadline, which is set by the sentencing schedule.
Writer's checklist
- Addressed to the sentencing judge by name, as counsel directs.
- States the relationship and how long you have known the defendant.
- Includes at least two specific, firsthand examples.
- Acknowledges the conviction without arguing the facts.
- No request for a specific sentence.
- Truthful, signed, dated, with contact information.
- Sent to defense counsel for review before anything goes to the court.
Frequently asked questions
What is a mitigation letter in federal sentencing?
It is a letter to the sentencing judge, usually from someone who knows the defendant, describing the defendant's background, character and conduct from firsthand knowledge. Courts may consider that information under 18 U.S.C. § 3661 and must weigh the defendant's history and characteristics under 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a)(1).
Who should write a letter to the judge?
People with real, firsthand knowledge: family, employers, colleagues, clergy, community members, and, for clinical facts, treatment providers writing within their professional knowledge. Quality and specifics matter more than the number of letters or the writer's title.
Should the letter ask for a specific sentence?
Generally, no. Asking for a particular number of months is the attorney's role. Letters are strongest when they give the judge accurate, specific information the judge would not otherwise have.
Should letter writers discuss the facts of the case?
No. Writers should not dispute guilt, minimize the offense or describe the evidence. A writer can say they know about the conviction and still describe what they have seen of the defendant.
How are letters delivered to the judge?
Through defense counsel. Counsel decides which letters to submit, in what form and when, usually with or before the sentencing memorandum. Writers should not send letters to the judge directly unless counsel tells them to.
Build the whole record, not just the letters
Letters are one part of the history-and-characteristics record. Joseph De Gregorio works with defense counsel on the full record. See federal sentencing reduction and early release strategy.
Request a Private Case ReviewCall 646-588-8182joseph@sentencingadvocacygroup.comSentencing Advocacy Group is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice or legal representation. Joseph De Gregorio is a federal sentencing reduction and early release strategist who works alongside defense counsel. Nothing on this page creates an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not predict future outcomes.
Cite this page
Joseph De Gregorio, "How to Write a Mitigation Letter for Federal Sentencing," Sentencing Advocacy Group (updated November 16, 2026), https://sentencingadvocacygroup.com/mitigation-letter-federal-sentencing
Sources
- 18 U.S.C. § 3661; 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a).
- U.S. Sentencing Commission, Guidelines Manual (2026), §1B1.4.
- Fed. R. Crim. P. 32.